The new shape Honda civic is worse looking than a 1 series.
Yes honda's are reliable but that's only there v tec units.
BMW diesel are great very smooth power unlike vag diesel which are just wam bam thank you mam.
The 1 series chassis is very good. Once you get used to rwd and there is a huge difference in the rain lol.
But the whole idea of buying a diesel is to save money when doing big miles if not buy the 135 I and have that mapped.
Rob have a look on babybmw for info on the 1 series. The 118d is a good engine it's the injectors that limit it's performance. But it's still capable of pushing out 185 bhp when mapped which for a car with 30 quid a year road tax is good.